I have been biting my tongue... or sitting on my hands per se.... about why I did not attend the
SNAG conference this year. I live in Savannah - the conference was in Savannah - the fact that I did not have to travel or pay for a hotel should have been reason enough. But I did not. Ok, actually, I did attend a portion of the
Professional Development Seminar. But, I went so that I might be able to finally meet some of the people who I've only corresponded with online.
Anyway......
There is an interesting dialog going on on
Annie's (of imogene) blog. There were some disheartening comments made by a metalsmithing "elder" during one of the lectures. Annie bravely confronted these comments
in this post on her blog. After reading the entry and subsequent comments, my head felt like it was about to explode.
My disheartening with the metalsmith/SNAG community happened long ago. Although I had worked with metal in my dad's machine shop since I was a child, I never considered it a possible career. But somehow when I was in my early 20's I took a metals class at the
Oregon College of Art and Craft. I could not believe how naturally making the work came to me, and I fell in love with it. I was at OCAC about a year and then I transferred to the University of Oregon. This is where the downslide began.
During my second term at the UO a German metalsmith, Bettina Dittleman, was brought in as a visiting professor. Bettina had an amazing approach - it was all about experimentation - she had the philosophy that if you wanted to know a technique then read a book and do it. She rarely gave opinions on work, instead said "keep going!" She also stated from the beginning of class that she didn't believe in grades and that everyone automatically got an A. Well, Bettina's approach was not keenly accepted by those in charge, and after a year, she left the UO seemingly unhappy about her experience.
I was told by the subsequent visiting professor that I didn't belong in metals classes. Since I had my own workshop, I had been doing much of my work there. The metals class also did an "interactive" show one term where my contribution was hand cast (literally cast in the palm of my hand) chocolate. I was also leaning into books arts a bit and trying to incorporate the two mediums. I felt like I was making my work my own.... I was taking a multidisciplinary approach. I don't think that this professor was trying to dig at me by saying that I didn't belong, because we then talked about schools that had interdisciplinary programs. But, she was letting me know that there were fairly rigid parameters to the label metalsmith, and I took it to heart. For me, metals was a foundation. It was a secure jumping point from which I took on other mediums.
I left college one credit short of graduating. I just stopped caring. I didn't make anything for a long time and referred to this lapse as being "in recovery from art school." But, while in school, I did attend one SNAG conference - that was my first and last.
I have always felt that the SNAG community is cliquish, that the mentality is rigid and resistant to change, that much of the "acknowledged" work is overworked and heavy handed - it is metalsmithing for metalsmiths. I look at websites like
Klimt02 and see a freshness and vitality in the work - most of this work is from non-US artists.
I also am put off by the BFA/MFA elitism. Strangely enough, it seems frowned upon to make a living off your work...unless you are teaching. And then there's the whole who's who when it comes to professorship.
Now, I do see a lot of poorly crafted work on
Etsy and indie craft shows, but these are venues and tools for crafters/artists and buyers of many types. I see it this way - the wider the variety of work, the larger the visual lexicon for the consumer. Appreciation for quality work can only come through comparison. The American populace needs as much exposure to the arts as it can get.
Now, for the shocker.....
I think I will attend the SNAG conference next year. I think I might even subscribe to Metalsmith magazine. Why? People are talking; people like Annie are voicing themselves. People like Rebecca Scheer are making changes to the accessibility of the metalsmith medium through shows like
Touching Warms the Art. Metalsmiths are starting to "straddle the fence," as
Megan Auman stated. I see the definition of "metalsmith" expanding. I can see the American metalsmithing community coming out of a deep stagnation, and that may be a very exciting thing to be a part of.